I read it in one sitting. Could not put it down. The conversations between Mack and "Papa" covered a spectrum of emotions and dialogue that hit so close to home that it was almost like reading my own journal. It is amazing that he was able to convey so accurately the spiritual and psychological turmoil that a family goes through when a loved one goes missing.

I acknowledge that the way he presents the trinity is controversial, but I am not at all offended. Our own perceptions of God as "father" are so wrapped up in our own earthly relationship with our own father that I think it is perfectly natural for the character of Mack to resist the expected perception. I think it was honest of the character. And I hope it will help others work through their own resistance to relating to GOD as FATHER.

As we all witnessed toward the end, Mack's description, perception and relationship with Papa began to evolve...and that I think is the important thing. God meets us at our need and presents Himself as the answer to all our needs. God has a maternal aspect that may be much more comfortable to approach or trust than someone, for example, who was abused by an earthly father. This should not be hard to understand.

If I use the term "Ishi" (beloved Husband) when I pray, am I being disrespectful of "Abba"? If I use the term "Rahpa", am I limiting Him to only my healer? No, I do not think so. I am communicating with the God whom I know will respond to how my heart needs Him at the moment. He is ALL...everything and has many names, many faces when I look into it and many voices when I listen. While all the time...here is the kicker...never changing. He is the same yesterday, today and tomorrow. I think Mr. Young has given us a very unique and thought-provoking way to see and dialogue with..."Papa"

I am looking forward to reading the book again to examine more of the doctrine of the dialogues now that I have enjoyed the fictional aspect of the mystery. But these comments are my first impressions of the book. I am extremely interested in hearing other comments.

-deb harrell, editor
www.shatteredpots.com